Master of Orion 2 from the 90s is what you call in the music business an evergreen, and some people still have and play it even today. It consolidated an emerging new type of 4X-gameplay into a coherent, complex, personal experience. Statistics, battles, ship and planet building, ground battles, and characters to identify with, character data and portraits included. Many games tried to copy this level of perfection and failed. If there was one with a good potential to go new yet familiar routes in this genre, it would have been Ascendancy or Stars!, also from the late 90s, but sadly, those got never beyond what you could count as an "early access" state of development.
And we do not speak of Master of Orion 3; given it´s glaring shortcomings, most fans even deny that it exists. Funny, I count myself to that crowd and when I installed now the new game from the bundled sale, I just clicked on Master of Orion 3, because, this one is the third one, right?
I have played two campaigns so far, one with a diplomatic victory, by paying to get the votes of the next biggest competitor, and a scientific victory.
The game does a lot of things right and gives me for a large part the good old MoO2 with modern, beautiful graphic and voiceovers. I am a total sucker for a nice, involving yet clean user interface, loved for example Ascendancy for that, and despite Paradox´ Stellaris probably shaping up to be a better and more complex 4X-game, MoO´s beatiful user interface and graphics won me over once more. However, I have to criticise that there are too little new elements, and the elements that are new all seem to go down the same unfamous lane of dumbing down complexity. The charm of MoO2 was that you had a fair amount of complexity, which was easy to handle at the same time. Give us something new and complex, not just something replacing and dumbing down old stuff!
- Tactical combat: Lot´s of fandom discussion here. Having been a fan of the super nerdy Stars! back in the 90ties, and also being roughly familiar with GalCiv, I can see the charm. Especially with added control options, I can have an almost turn-based level of control on distance and holding fire, speed and positioning. Did not figure out yet how to control the special equipment precisely enough (better feedback on pressed buttons is required in general pls), but with some refining I can see a lot of fun. Love the cinematic intro on each battle; maybe some more variety here? Seeing those missiles homing in, seeing them shot down by pooint defenses and then impacts in life-action mode, this never gets old for me. I also love the difference between unguided torpedoes and guided missiles. Dodging a torpedo salvo with fast ships can make a decisive difference (if the teleporter device would be quicker to act, I would love to use it also to this ends!).
- Starlanes, later the jumpgates: Also a topic for a lot of fandom discussion. Especially playing with a spiral galaxy, it seems that there is a race for unlocking those unstable starlanes in order to get to the unsettled center worlds. I treat it like a special game mode, and it is interesting, but I sure would like to have other options, including a “free-flight” option, or having racial options like Paradox´ Stellaris is going to give you on each race´s FTL-technology. However, I would have preferred a totally different route: Actual fuel use, refilling at gas giants. This would be more complex than MoO2 and a challenge for the oftenly under-represented eXploration part of the game.
- Tech tree: In MoO2, I always played with the “creative” trait, because I cannot miss things. However, in this new iteration of MoO, a bit more diversity in the current tech development for each campaign would be really nice. Maybe by adding a cost penalty, the more tech you have? Would make sense then to tech trade or have tech-treaties with other races.
- Currently, the micromanagement gets painful due to bad AI-build queues. I read that customisable auto-build queues are coming; good! They should make the list of buildings as part of the same screen; having to do extra clicks just to see and dismiss this list is awful.
-The spy game: A bit slow moving. Once a spy gets uncovered, you basically have to restart from scratch. No idea how big chances are that a given spy gets discovered. Maybe a bit more transparency here?
- Uber-planets are a nice new game mechanic, countering that late game symptom of having only gaja-type planets. Also, a galaxy without gas giants seems boring. Maybe some alternate use for them instead of turning them barren?
- More mid- to late-game incentives required: Right now it is just a grind or a rampage right after the first 100 turns. Economic collapses, diseases, diverging factions in your empire, special scientific findings leading to unique tech, and where are the invading Antarians?
- Government types? Religions? Inter-racial conflicts? Free movement of people/races between planets? Missing! Why!?
- I loved how Alpha Centauri played with the tropes and impacts of technology on society. How does cybernetics change your race´s culture? What about the impact of genetics, psionics?
- Viability of different combat styles? Would love to build some suicide frigates with quantum detonators and teleporters and screw them all! More transparency on combat data would be also nice.
- I loved in Alpha Centauri, where you could basically create your slave race by conquering a race and granting them peace in their most despaired last moment, or when freeing their leader: They could never again betray you. Maybe MOO could also include such a mechanic of creating a vassal faction out of a conquered race, instead of just exterminating them?
- Having figureheads makes a game more personal. Admirals, spy-chiefs, governors; any plans on adding that? How about unique ships, e.g. stolen from the Antarans (my fun sport in late game MoO2).
- Right now I cannot upgrade non-combat ships if I miss it at the point when I get the tech upgrade.
- A pet peeve of mine since I played Ascendancy: Non-humanoid, non-podic races, please! And I want my favourite Trilarians and those telepathic dark elves! (Come on, in light of all possible alien diversity, nobody needs two human race portraits and voiceovers!)
- For mid-game, I would like to see which of my races does sit in which colony ship, please.
- Arming space stations and military outposts via the ship builder was already a persistent wish of the MOO2 crowd. It´s still not in.
- A ship arriving at a point with an inactive fleet makes that ship also inactive, without warning. Same with space factories after they finished a construction.
- Victory videos, please! Some reward and final acknowledgement for those long-fought-out games! Again, Alpha Centauri did this very well! But also the evil laugh about the “Master of Orion” was just great.